Tyler spends his days painting and missing his family. He has dreams of running towards the ocean holding a child’s shoe. So I assume his child drowned. His friend Rose is concerned about his isolation because she’s his closest neighbor for miles. This becomes a confusing plot point when it is revealed he lives downtown. We can see people walking by the front door as she talks to him, and there are shops and homes along the lane.
One night Tyler finds an injured woman on the beach and brings her back to his house. He promises to help her, but she doesn’t talk since she’s using her siren song to keep him under control.
Some old friends come into town and Tyler rents a house to them. When one of them disappears, they ask Tyler if their missing friend is with him, but he acts weird and won’t let them in. One looks through the window and becomes alarmed when he sees the mermaid. If I looked in an artist's window and saw a mermaid, I’d think someone was posing for a painting. Inexplicably the mermaid can paint.
Things keep going off the rails and Rose tries to save Tyler because she is a witch. Yes, there is also witchcraft in the village, which is also not mentioned as a cause for concern. People should just stay out of this town, what with the roving band of killer mermaids and the inconspicuous witches.
Ridiculous dialogue
I’m just your neighbor. The closet one for miles anywhere.
![]() |
| More concerned about keeping his cap at a jaunty angle |
![]() |
| Boom mic alert |
![]() |
| Poor Tyler’s home is so isolated he has no neighbors for miles. |
![]() |
| No one shall notice the mermaid hiding in the grass |



























